Research on the core elements and response mechanism of organized research in universities

Abstract

Abstract: In the era of big science,organized research in universities has become an important form of providing systematic and institutionalized support for national strategic needs.Based on the data related to the three major State Science and Technology Awards in universities from 2010 to 2020, this research focuses on award-winning teams and adopts a combination of mathematical statistics and case studies to analyze the basic conditions and principles of the role of core elements in organized research, systematically deconstructs and enriches the connotation and extension of organized research in universities.The research finds that the National Natural Science Foundation (NSFC),State Key Laboratories and Key Laboratories of the Ministry of Education, multi-Principal Investigator (PI) cross-border teams,system and mechanism as well as culture play key roles in organized research practices. Based on the integrated route of “project traction, platform integration, team tackling, and ecology supporting”, the research proposes targeted suggestions to promote the construction of organized research system in universities with Chinese characteristics and provide scientifically and feasibly oriented solutions to enhance the effectiveness of organized research in universities.

摘要： 在大科学时代，高校有组织科研成为建制化、体系化服务国家战略需求的重要形式。研究基于高校2010年-2020年国家科学技术三大奖相关数据，以获奖团队为研究对象，采用数理统计和案例研究相结合的方法，分析高校有组织科研核心要素作用发挥的基本条件和原理，系统解构并丰富高校有组织科研的内涵和外延。研究发现，国家自然科学基金、国家重点实验室和教育部重点实验室、多PI（Principal Investigator）跨边界团队、体制机制和文化在有组织科研实践中至关重要，对于制定加强有组织科研策略具有基础性作用。基于“项目牵引、平台集成、团队攻关、生态支撑”的一体化路线，研究提出了建立多元化长效稳定资助机制以发挥竞争性和稳定性资助支撑效能、基于各层次科研平台的明确定位进行任务统筹以取得集成性成果、引领多PI跨边界团队协同攻关以打破组织边界壁垒并降低成本、重视生态建设以盘活有组织科研全局的核心要素发展思路，能够推进构建具有中国特色的高校有组织科研体系，为提升高校有组织科研效能提供兼具科学性和可行性的问题解决方案。

赵宏媚赵文华姚建建. 高校有组织科研核心要素响应机制研究[J]. 科学学研究, 2024, 42(10): 2130-2137.

References

参考文献： [1] Geiger L.Organized Research Units-Their Role in the Development of University Research[J].The Journal of Higher Education,1990,61(1):1–19. [2] 杜鹏，沈华，张凤.对科学研究的新认识[J].中国科学院院刊,2021,36(12):1413-1418. Du P,Shen H,Zhang F.New Understanding on Scientific Research[J].Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences,2021,36(12):1413-1418. [3] Whitley R. Changing governance of the sciences:The advent of research evaluation systems[J].Science and public policy, 2002,29(6):381-394. [4] Etzkowitz H, Kemelgo C.The Role of Research Centres in the Collectivisation of Academic Science[J].Minerva,1998,36(3) :271–288. [5] Clark B R.Creating Entrepreneurial Universities: Organizational Pathways of Transformation[M].Oxford: Pergamon Press for the International Association of Univ,1998. [6] Zollo, M., & Winter, S. G. (2002). Deliberate learning and the evolution of dynamic capabilities. Organization Science, 13(3), 339-351. [7] Jacobsson S., Johnson A.The diffusion of renewable energy technology:An analytical framework and key issues for research[J].Energy Policy,2000,28(9):625-640. [8] 赵红光,阎维杰.我国转型期的特点及其对有组织科技活动的影响[J].中国软科学,2001,(11):86-90. Zhao H G,Yan W J.Characteristics of Chinese Transition and Its Influence on Organized S&T Activities[J]. China Soft Science,2001,(11):86-90. [9] Sa C M.University-based Research Centers:Characteristics,Organization,and Administrative Implications[J].Journal of Research Administration,2008,39(1)：32-40. [10] Barton H.Paul Lazarsfeld and Applied Social Research: Invention of the University Applied Social Research Institute[J].Social Science History,1979,(3)：4-44. [11] Orea R A, Carmelo G P. The Business Model and Its Core Elements. Proposal of Definition and Table of Core Elements[J].Contemporary Economics,2018,12(4):497-517. [12] Furman J L.,Stern S. Climbing atop the shoulders of giants: The impact of institutions on cumulative research[J]. American Economic Review,2011,101(5):1933-1963. [13] Fleming L., Sorenson O. Science as a map in technological search[J].Strategic Management Journal,2004,25(8-9),909-928. [14] Manz C.,Sims H.Leading workers to lead themselves:The external leadership of self-managing work teams[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1987,32:106-128. [15] Terstriep J., Rehfeld D., Kleverbeck M.Favourable social innovation ecosystem(s) An explorative approach, European Planning Studies,2020,28(5):881-905. [16] 赵哲,陶如钰,李鑫容.大学与战略性新兴产业协同发展的外域检视与本土路径[J].现代教育管理,2023,No.398(05):62-71. Zhao Z,Tao R Y,Li X R.External Review and Local Path for Synergistic Development of Universities and Strategic Emerging Industries[J].Modern Education Management,2023,No.398(05):62-71. [17] 植林,刘思莞.基于高校新型研发机构的粤港澳大湾区产教融合路径研究[J].科技管理研究,2023,43(05):74-80. Zhi L,Liu S W. Research on the Integration Path of Industry and Education in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area Based on New Type R&D Institutions in Colleges[J].Science and Technology Management Research,2023,43(05):74-80. [18] DE WECK,OLIVIER L.Research And Development Project Definition And Portfolio Management.Technology Roadmapping and Development[M].Switzerland:Springer International AG,2022: 447-483. [19] Katzenbach J R , Smith D K.The Wisdom of teams:creating the high-performance organization[M].Harvard Business School Press Boston,1994. [20] 元素有机化学国家重点实验室.实验室介绍[EB/OL].(2022-10-1)[2023-1-2]http://skleoc.nankai.edu.cn/sysjs.htm. State Key Laboratory of Elemento-organic Chemistry.Introduction[EB/OL].(2022-10-1)[2023-1-2]http://skleoc.nankai.edu.cn/sysjs.htm. [21] Nelson R.National innovation systems: A comparative analysis[M].Oxford University Press,1993. [22] Powell W., Koput W., Smith-Doerr L. Interorganizational collaboration and the locus of innovation: Networks of learning in biotechnology[J].Administrative science quarterly, 1996,41(1):116-145. [23] O'Reilly C. A.,Chatman J. Culture as social control:Corporations, cults, and commitment[J].Research in Organizational Behavior, 1996,18(1):157-200. [24] Carayannis G,Campbell J.Mode 3 and Quadruple Helix:toward a 21st Century Fractal innovation Ecosystem[J].International Journal of Technology Management,2009,46(3):201-234. [25] Porter M E.Clusters and the new economics of competition[J].Harvard Business Review,1998,76(6),77-90. [26] 孙凝晖.新型举国体制下对国家重点实验室重组的战略思考[J].中国科学院院刊,2022, 37(12):1833-1839.Sun N H.Strategic Thoughts on Reconstruction of State Key Laboratories under New Nationwide System[J].Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences,2022,37(12):1833-1839. [27] Moore J F.Predators and Prey: A New Ecology of Competition[J].Harvard Business Review 1993,71(3):75. [28] Uzzi B., Spiro J. Collaboration and creativity:The small world problem[J].American journal of sociology,2005,111(2):447-504. [29] 魏江,赵雨菡.数字创新生态系统的治理机制[J].科学学研究,2021,39(06):965-969. Wei J,Zhao Y H.Governance mechanism of digital innovation ecosystem[J].Studies in Science of Science,2021,39(06):965-969. [30] Peltoniemi M J.Preliminary Theoretical Framework for the Study of Business Ecosystems[J].Emergence (Mahwah, N.J.),2006,8 (1):10.